Where should I handle sorting in Redux App?

- 1 answer


I have an action / reducer / components. In one of my components (component dump) I have a Select. I get information on what type of filter my store. Where can I handle it in action, or reducer?




I save the items, sortKey and sortKind (asc/desc) in the Redux Store.

In my Angular component (I believe would be same for React), I get the store state as an Observable so that I can display the items, sortKey and sortOrder in the UX.

When the user clicks on the table columns to change sort key (order) I dispatch the new keys/sort order to reducer for the state.

The reducer then performs the new sorting, and returns the new state with the updated values.

The Observable in the component thus sparks an event which updates the UX.


  • keep sorting logic out of the component

  • by saving the sortKey and sortKind in the state, you can restore precisely the UX if the user refreshes the browser (I use Redux-LocalStorage to sync)

  • as the store has the sorted items, you'll only perform sorting when the user actively wants it.

  • the sorted items are remembered for when the user might return to the component.

My reducer ( "bizzes" is my items list, and I use Immutable.List to store the items)

import { List }                     from 'immutable';
import { IBizz, IBizzState }   from './bizz.types';
import { BIZZES_SET, BIZZES_SORT}    from 'store/constants';

const SORT_ASC = 'asc';
const SORT_DESC = 'desc';

const defaultSortKey = 'serialNo';
const defaultSortOrder = SORT_ASC;

const INITIAL_STATE: IBizzState =  {
    bizzes: List([]),
    sortKey: defaultSortKey,
    sortOrder: defaultSortOrder

export function bizzReducer(state: IBizzState = INITIAL_STATE, action: any): IBizzState {

    switch (action.type) {

        case BIZZES_SET:
            return {
                bizzes: List(action.payload.bizzes),
                sortKey: action.payload.sortKey || defaultSortKey,
                sortOrder: action.payload.sortOrder || defaultSortOrder

        case BIZZES_SORT:
            let sortKey = action.payload.sortKey || defaultSortKey;

            if(sortKey === state.sortKey) {
                state.sortOrder = state.sortOrder === SORT_ASC ? SORT_DESC : SORT_ASC;

            return {
                bizzes: List(state.bizzes.sort( (a, b) => { 
                    if( a[sortKey] < b[sortKey] ) return state.sortOrder === SORT_ASC ? -1 : 1;
                    if( a[sortKey] > b[sortKey] ) return state.sortOrder === SORT_ASC ? 1: -1;
                    return 0;
                sortKey: sortKey,
                sortOrder: state.sortOrder
        default: return state;

And my component ( I use Ng2-Redux to get the store as Observables):

import { Component, OnInit, OnDestroy, ChangeDetectionStrategy } from '@angular/core';
import { select } from 'store';
import { BizzActions } from 'actions/index';

    selector: 'bizzlist',
    templateUrl: './bizz-list.html',
    changeDetection: ChangeDetectionStrategy.OnPush
export class BizzListComponent implements OnInit {

    @select([ 'bizzState']) bizzState$;

    public sortOrder: string;
    public sortKey: string;
    public bizzes = [];
    private bizzStateSubscription; 

        public bizzActions: BizzActions
    ) { }

    ngOnInit() {
        this.bizzStateSubscription = this.bizzState$.subscribe( bizzState => {
            this.bizzes = bizzState.bizzes;
            this.sortKey = bizzState.sortKey;
            this.sortOrder = bizzState.sortOrder;

    ngOnDestroy() {

    public sortBizzes(key) {

As you can see, I am using an Action (called BizzActions) to do the actual Redux dispatch. You could do it in your component, but I prefer to separate these things. For good measure, here's my BizzActions (a Service):

import { Injectable }           from '@angular/core';
import { NgRedux, IAppState }   from 'store';
import { 
} from 'store/constants';

export class BizzActions {

    constructor (private ngRedux: NgRedux<IAppState>) {}

    public setBizzes = (bizzes: any) => {
        return this.ngRedux.dispatch({
            type: BIZZES_SET,
            payload: {
                bizzes: bizzes

    public sortBizzes = (key:string) => {
        return this.ngRedux.dispatch({
            type: BIZZES_SORT,
            payload: {
                sortKey: key

source: stackoverflow.com