How To Setup A Project With Multiple Levels Of Modules For Local Development
I have multiple app projects of of roughly this layout:
- example app (Java)
- Java Wrapper with additional functionality
- C++ + Shallow Java Wrapper
- Java Wrapper with additional functionality
- 2nd example app (flutter)
- flutter wrapper
- Java Wrapper with additional functionality
- C++ + Shallow Java Wrapper
- Java Wrapper with additional functionality
- flutter wrapper
- 3rd example app
- flutter wrapper
- Java Wrapper with additional functionality
- C++ + Shallow Java Wrapper
- Java Wrapper with additional functionality
- flutter wrapper
All apps share the same main dependency (java Wrapper with additional functionality) and its dependency tree. Now I am developing on each app all the way down to C++ code. They are managed as git submodules in their respective parent project.
As there is a high change rate along the whole process, I want the final example to be built for testing from all sources.
I tried several approaches for tying this together into one gradle build:
1. Preferred (but failing) solution: settings.gradle in each project, each project only includes direct dependencies
Now I want this full tree to be managed in one flutter build. So I add the direct dependencies in each projects settings.gradle, just to learn that gradle only supports one toplevel settings.gradle
. So this does not work. The presented solutions in aforementioned question mostly try to emulate support for multiple settings.gradle files.
2. Functioning but Ugly: Add all dependency projects are included in the toplevel settings.gradle
Do I really have to include all subprojects manually in the toplevel settings.gradle
, when each of the subprojects knows its dependencies perfectly fine? Furthermore, since there are multiple projects depending on this, do I have to do this manually for each of them?
(And don't even get me startet about gradle not telling me, I have a wrong projectDir because I got a typo in the 100rth level of recursive descend!)
3. Probably Working Solution: Use composite builds
This will trigger the builds but now I have to resolve the build artifacts instead of the projects. So same problem with other artifacts.
4. Probably Working solution: Publish dependency projects to a maven (or other) repository and pull that into the app
I did not try this because I find the idea abhorent: I want to test one small change in the C++ code and now have to push that to a repository and potentially do the same on every project above? This works for a stable project but not for flexible exploratory development. Sure, I want to publish something at the end but I don't want to publish every little step in between.
This left me wondering: Am I doing something unusual? I mean: is there nobody who has the same requirements that gradle does not seem able to fit:
- live updates from all the way down to quick test local changes
- no repeating of transitive dependencies on the toplevel
What is the common practice in this case?
Answer
After Lukas Körfer's comment I took a closer look at composite builds again and noticed that I had a misconception about them. I did not understand that their dependency resolution will solve the finding of the build artifacts for me.
Now I use the composite builds to tie together the whole build while using
implementation 'my.group:project'
to import the code of the subprojects and
includeBuild '../path/to/subproject/'
to pull them in.
Related Questions
- → How to update data attribute on Ajax complete
- → October CMS - Radio Button Ajax Click Twice in a Row Causes Content to disappear
- → Octobercms Component Unique id (Twig & Javascript)
- → Passing a JS var from AJAX response to Twig
- → Laravel {!! Form::open() !!} doesn't work within AngularJS
- → DropzoneJS & Laravel - Output form validation errors
- → Import statement and Babel
- → Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property '__SECRET_DOM_DO_NOT_USE_OR_YOU_WILL_BE_FIRED' of undefined
- → React-router: Passing props to children
- → ListView.DataSource looping data for React Native
- → Can't test submit handler in React component
- → React + Flux - How to avoid global variable
- → Webpack, React & Babel, not rendering DOM